Poland’s Foreign Minister, Radosław Sikorski, has publicly accused Elon Musk’s Starlink satellite internet service of “making money on war crimes.” The accusation came in a post on the US social media platform X on Tuesday, where Sikorski claimed that Starlink is being used by Russian forces to carry out drone attacks in Ukraine.
Starlink Faces Harsh Criticism from Polish Official Over War Crimes
Starlink, operated by Musk’s SpaceX, has been a critical part of Ukraine’s defense since Russia launched its full-scale invasion in February 2022. After Russian strikes destroyed much of the country’s communications network, Starlink helped Ukrainian forces maintain internet access, allowing them to coordinate military operations, communicate with civilian authorities, and manage battlefield logistics. Analysts say the system has given Ukraine a technological edge in the conflict.
However, Sikorski’s statements suggest that the same technology may now be aiding Russia. The Polish minister argued that despite repeated assurances from Musk and his company that Starlink would not be available to Russian forces, the satellite service has somehow become part of Russia’s battlefield infrastructure.
“Starlink is making money on war crimes,” Sikorski wrote. He emphasized that the satellite connectivity enabling Russian drone operations directly contributes to attacks on Ukrainian civilians and military targets. His comments reignite longstanding concerns about private tech companies’ role in modern warfare, particularly when their products are used in ways that may violate international law.
Musk’s Role and Previous Disputes
The criticism adds to a long-running public dispute between Sikorski and Elon Musk. Last year, Musk responded dismissively when Sikorski questioned Starlink’s role in the conflict. In a widely shared exchange online, Musk called the Polish minister a “little man,” highlighting tensions between European officials and the tech billionaire over the use of private technologies in war zones.
Starlink’s situation is complex. While it has been a lifeline for Ukraine, reports from 2023 suggested that Russian forces may have found ways to exploit the system. No one fully knows the exact extent of Russian access to Starlink, but the possibility has raised questions about how tech companies operating in conflict zones should take accountability and responsibility.
Russia eyes new space weapon that could disrupt Starlink and reshape low Earth orbit
Experts warn that if forces use Starlink technology to carry out attacks, the system could indirectly enable war crimes, raising legal and ethical concerns. These concerns highlight the unintended consequences of providing advanced technology in active war zones.
Sikorski’s accusations also spark a broader debate about private companies’ responsibilities in modern conflicts. Unlike governments, tech firms like SpaceX operate globally and may unintentionally provide services to multiple sides in a conflict. Critics say companies must actively prevent hostile forces from using their technologies to commit war crimes or harm civilians, making accountability a pressing issue.
Starlink’s Impact on the Ukraine War
Since the Russian invasion began, Starlink has played a key role in keeping Ukraine connected. The satellite internet system replaced damaged communications infrastructure, allowing government offices, military units, hospitals, and civilians to maintain online access. This connectivity has been vital for coordinating defense operations and supporting daily life amid ongoing Russian attacks.
However, Poland’s foreign minister has raised concerns about the risks of advanced technology falling into the wrong hands. Satellite internet, while designed for global coverage, can allow forces to exploit it in conflicts where secure and fast communication is critical for military operations.
Starlink Under Siege: Russia Targets Ukrainian Networks
Sikorski’s comments highlight the ethical and legal challenges of modern warfare. Even though companies like SpaceX do not participate directly in combat, hostile forces may misuse their technology and unintentionally commit war crimes.
Starlink remains central to Ukraine’s defense, but Russian forces’ potential misuse has sparked international debate. Policymakers, analysts, and human rights organizations are now questioning whether tech companies can control how people use their products and whether they bear responsibility for enabling war crimes.